12 Best Places to Sell Board Games – Near You & Online!

BoardGameCo has a want list on its site. The company says that it will often offer much less for games that are not on its want list.

Just send the company a list of games you’re interested in selling, and any details like the condition the games are in, and the company will get back to you, usually within 2 business days, with a quote for both cash payments and store credit.

Simply fill out the online form to get started.

If you like the company’s offer, you can ship your board games to the company. On larger purchases, BoardGameCo will cover the shipping costs.

In general, the company will pay you around 25% to 50% of the market value for a game on its want list, but potentially less than that if the company is overstocked on that particular game. With store credit, you can get an additional 30% back.

2. eBay

eBay is a good place to sell board games because you can set your own prices. eBay gets millions of visitors each money, so with just one quick listing, you could reach a huge customer base. Sure, not every one of those people is going to see your listing, but many will.

You can reach customers all over the world, meaning your income isn’t limited to just who’s willing to purchase the tapes locally.

You can list up to 50 items for free on eBay.

When your board games sell, you’ll be charged a 10% commission fee. This will cut into your profits somewhat.

However, you’ll still likely earn more on eBay than you would selling to a place like BoardGameCo. This is because on eBay you’re selling directly to the customer.

With BoardGameCo and stores like that, you’re selling to a store that will then resell your game to customers for a profit. This means the price the store offers you will generally be less. For example, a store may offer you $14 for a Monopoly board game, and then resell it for $25.

On eBay, however you can set your own price and sell directly to the customer, meaning you get a higher profit from the sale, even after eBay has taken its 10% commission fee.

3. OfferUp

OfferUp is a website and app where people can buy and sell things locally or online. You can list your board games for sale on there. It’s free to list items for sale on OfferUp.

You can sell board games to people locally or you can ship them to the buyer. If you do choose to ship your board games, you will have to pay a service fee. The fee is either a minimum of $1.99 or 12.9% of the sale price.

4. BoardGameGeek

BoardGameGeek is an online forum for board game hobbyists. The site offers reviews, ratings, videos, photos and more all about board games. You can actually list your unwanted board games for sale in the BoardGameGeek Marketplace.

You can choose the payment option you want, like PayPal or bank transfer. BoardGameGeek takes a 3% commission.

You can also sell items through GeekList Auction. GeekList Auctions are not for selling items at a set price. Instead, items are sold to the highest bidder.

5. Craigslist

Another place you can sell board games near you is on Craigslist. If you don’t mind meeting up with someone to sell your board games locally, then try Craigslist.

You can list items for sale for free on Craigslist and it doesn’t charge you any commission either.

So, you can keep 100% of your profits! You get to set your own price, which means you can get more cash than you would if you were selling to somewhere like BoardGameCo.

6. Noble Knight Games

Noble Knight Games is another place to sell board games. Noble Knight Games purchases 1,000s of gaming products for cash or store credit. You can sell your board games to the company, and other gaming products like trading card games, such as Yu-Gi-Oh cards and Pokémon cards.

Simply, provide the company with a list of items you want to sell, and you’ll get a quote within a few business days. The quote will show you what you can expect to earn for your items in cash, store credit, or both. You’ll get a higher quote for store credit than you will for cash.

The company has a list of what it buys on the site. You can find the link to that on the page linked above.

If you like the quote and decide to sell your board games to Noble Knight Games, then you can either ship your items to the company or drop them off in-store at the company’s store in Madison, Wisconsin.

The company will pay for shipping in most cases.

The company typically processes your items within 1 to 2 business days of arrival. If you opt for a cash payment, it provides payment through PayPal or Business Check either by mail or in-person.

7. r/BoardGameExchange on Reddit

The r/BoardGameExchange subreddit is another place to sell board games. It’s a trading community for tabletop games. In this subreddit, you can trade, sell, and barter for games.

What’s great about listing a game for sale on Reddit is that you can set your own prices. This gives you more control over what you earn than you would get with companies like BoardGameCo and Noble Knight Games, which give you quotes.

Best Places to Sell Board Games for Cash Near You

If you would rather sell your vintage and valuable board games to a person directly, these are your best options.

8. Local board game and hobby stores

Another option you could try is local board games and hobby shops. Some shops will purchase people’s collections to resell them.

You can find stores by searching for the term, “Board game stores near me” on Google. Get in touch to see if stores near you purchase used board games.

Again, like with Noble Knight Games and BoardGameCo, you will likely get low offers for your board games, because the store wants to make a profit reselling your games.

It’s important to know the value of your games so that you can decide whether or not an offer is acceptable.

9. Flea market

You could consider selling board games at a flea market. This is a particularly good option if you have other items to sell as well. You could clear out your home and make a little extra cash.

What’s good about flea markets is that you can often tap into a market of customers that you may not find online. And, you can get cash on the spot too.

The only issue with flea markets is that you’ll typically need to pay to rent a table or booth, the cost of which can cut into your profits. It’s still an option worth considering though because you can set your own prices and get paid fast.

10. 5miles

5miles is a website and app where you can buy and sell items locally. You can list your board games for sale there.

It’s free to list items on there. And, you get to set your own price too.

11. Facebook Marketplace

Facebook Marketplace is a platform where you can sell a variety of items locally. You can list items for sale for free on there!

Also, you can set your own price for selling your board games. So, you aren’t restricted to a quoted price like you are with companies like BoardGameCo.

It’s free to sell on Facebook Marketplace if you aren’t selling as a shop.

This means that if you are selling your board games to someone locally, you won’t have to pay any fees.

If you want to ship your items to a buyer though, then you will need to sell as a shop. This is because you can only use the shipping feature if you’re selling as a shop. You will have to pay a selling fee of 5% per shipment or a flat fee of $0.40 for shipments of $8 or less.

What’s great about selling on Facebook is that you get to set your own prices. This means you aren’t dependent on a store to give you a quote for your board games.

12. Yard sale

Although a little old-fashioned compared to some of the other options on the list like selling on eBay, having a yard sale can still be a good option. Just like with flea markets, yard sales allow you to tap into a market of people who don’t do much shopping online and prefer to shop in person instead.

With yard sales, you can get cash on the spot, and you get to set your own prices too.

The downside with yard sales though is that people are mostly there to find bargains, so you might not always get great value for your board games.

Closing Thoughts

There are lots of places where you can sell board games either online or near you. Give the places on our list a try if you’ve been wondering where to sell board games.