20 Best Places to Sell Sports Cards Near You & Online (for the Most Cash!)

You just need to know where to sell them!

Perhaps you’ve been collecting sports cards for a while and have decided to sell your collection. Maybe you inherited some cards from a family member and want to know where you can sell them. Or perhaps you just happened to come across some sports cards that you forgot you had while you were cleaning out the garage or the attic?

Whatever the case, if you’re looking to sell sports cards, you have plenty of options.

Below, I’ve covered 20 of the best places to sell sports cards both online and near you.

With the places below, you can sell:

• Baseball cards
• Football cards
• Boxing cards
• Basketball cards
• Hockey cards
• And plenty of other sports cards.

Where to Sell Sports Cards Online

Selling online is such a great option because it’s generally convenient and you can usually reach a wider range of buyers.

Selling online is definitely worth considering if you’re looking to make money selling sports cards.

Here are some great websites where you can sell sports cards.

1. Dean’s Cards

Dean’s Cards is one of the best places you can sell sports cards. The company sells more than 1,000 vintage baseball cards per day! And it maintains an inventory of more than 1 million cards, which makes it the largest online vendor for vintage cards.

You can sell a whole host of different sports cards on the site, including:

• Baseball cards
• Basketball cards
• Football cards
• Hockey cards
• Boxing cards

Dean’s Cards purchases almost any card from 1969 and before, and most complete sets through 1985.

Aside from some complete sets, Dean’s Cards rarely purchases cards that are newer than 1980, as the company says that many of them do not hold enough value.

According to Dean’s Cards, because the company sells directly, it can usually pay more money for your cards than you would get elsewhere.

You can complete the form on the site to get a free appraisal of your baseball cards.

You can mail your collection to the company. Its bid software generates an offer that’s based on current market prices and availability, and it sends you its best offer upfront.

If you don’t like the offer, the company will mail your collection back to you. According to Dean’s Cards, sellers end up accepting its bid more than 80% of the time.

2. eBay

One of the best places to sell used sports equipment as well as sports cards online is eBay. The site is super popular, with 159 million people active on eBay, and well-known so you can get your cards out there in front of tons of potential buyers.

If a buyer is online searching for the types of sports cards you’re selling, they could see your eBay listing, and you could make a sale!

You can list up to 250 items per month for free on eBay. That’s great, right? You’ll start paying a $0.35 insertion fee per listing if you list more than 250 items per month.

When you do sell your cards, eBay will charge you a final value fee, which, for most categories, is 12.9% of the sale price or lower, plus $0.30 per order.

Just keep these fees in mind when you are pricing your sports cards for sale on eBay.

3. Just Collect

Another place that you can sell sports cards is on Just Collect.

This is a website where you can sell vintage sports cards for cash. The company will purchase most vintage cards, which are those from 1979 or earlier. But, it only buys certain modern cards, which are those that were produced after 1979.

You can visit the Just Collect website (linked in the section heading above) to learn more about what types of cards the company purchases.

You can use the free appraisal form on the site to get started with selling your cards to the company and to find out how much your collection is worth.

You can mail your collection to Just Collect. It will pay for shipping and insurance, which is great.

If you prefer to sell your sports cards in person, then the company also allows you to drive to one of its appraisal locations or they can drive to you.

The company may even fly out to meet with you if you are far away and have a big collection.

Just Collect will purchase a variety of sports cards, such as:

• Baseball cards
• Basketball cards
• Football cards
• Hockey cards

4. Webstore

Webstore is an online auction site where you can sell your sports cards. The site actually allows you to sell stuff in multiple categories. It has a category just for sports cards and memorabilia, so you can sell your sports cards there.

The site is free to use. There are no registration or signup fees and no selling fees either. So, you get to keep 100% of the profits when your sports cards sell.

5. Blowout Cards Forum

Okay, so if you want to make some extra cash selling your sports cards, then I would recommend you consider the Blowout Cards Forum.

This is a forum where people discuss collecting sports cards and trading cards.

There’s actually a marketplace section (which I’ve linked to in the section heading) where you can sell all sorts of different cards, including:

• Baseball cards
• Football cards
• Basketball cards
• Hockey cards
• Soccer cards
• WWE and wrestling cards
• Vintage cards

You can post your cards for sale on there and see what people are looking to purchase.

The great thing about selling through these types of forums is that you can often find targeted buyers – many of whom are looking to purchase specific cards. You’re also able to set your own rates, within reason, of course, which is great.

6. Reddit

Reddit is another place where you can sell your sports cards.

You’ll find a variety of subreddits on there, each dedicated to a different type of sports trading card.

Here are some examples:

• r/baseballcards
• r/basketballcards
• r/footballcards
• r/soccercard

There’s also a subreddit for sports cards in general, called r/sportscards.

People use these subreddits to share sports cards and discuss them.

You can list your sports cards for sale on these subreddits. Just be sure to read and follow the subreddit rules!

7. DA Card World

DA Card World is a good site where you can sell sports cards online. The company purchases sealed boxes and cases of sports cards, and it also purchases modern sports card singles.

You can sell a multitude of sports cards to DA Card World, including:

• Baseball cards
• Basketball cards
• Football cards
• Hockey cards
• Soccer cards
• Boxing cards
• MMA cards
• F1 cards
• Golf cards

8. eBid

Another place where you can sell sports cards is eBid. It’s an online auction website that’s sort of like eBay where you can sell a whole bunch of different things, everything from toys and tools to furniture, clothing, and even sports tickets. This includes sports cards.

It’s a legit site with 4.1 stars on Trustpilot, which is a rating of “Great.”

9. Kruk Cards

Kruk Cards pays you for your sports cards. It’s a well-established place to sell, having been buying and selling for more than 30 years.

Kruk Cards will assess your cards and give you a quote. The company purchases collections large and small.

You can sell a variety of cards on there, including:

• Baseball cards
• Football cards
• Basketball cards
• Hockey cards
• Golf cards

10. Bonanza

Bonanza is an auction website where you can list sports cards for sale. It’s great for sellers because there are fewer sellers on there to compete with compared to eBay. Bonanza is home to just 25,000 sellers, which is way less than the 25 million sellers on eBay. This means that your listing is less likely to get lost among the competition.

There are no listing fees on there, which is great. When your item does sell, you have to pay a 3.5% commission fee. Consider this commission fee when pricing your sports cards for sale on there.

You can also opt-in to the site’s advertising program, and you can choose from a variety of different commission rates, including 9%, 13%, 19%, or 30%. And, according to Bonanza, higher rates mean more buyer visits from Google Shopping and other sources.

11. SportsCardPro

You can list baseball cards for sale on SportsCardPro.

There are lots of different categories on the site, such as:

• Sports cards
• Baseball cards
• Basketball cards
• Football cards
• Hockey cards
• Soccer cards
• Wrestling cards
• UFC cards

The site doesn’t charge listing fees, and it says that it doesn’t charge selling fees. However, you are charged a payment processing fee of 2.9% + 30¢ when your cards sell. You get paid to your PayPal account.

12. Atomic Mall

Atomic Mall is an online marketplace where you can sell your cards. The site has been around since 2008, so it’s well-established. You can sell a variety of items on there, including sports cards. The site has categories for different types of cards, such as:

• Basketball cards
• Football cards
• Golf cards
• Hockey cards
• NASCAR cards
• Soccer cards
• Tennis cards
• Baseball cards

You can set your own price when selling your items, which is good!

13. COMC (Check Out My Collectibles)

COMC is an online marketplace where you can buy and sell sports cards, comics, gaming cards, and more.

You can create a free account on the site and then send your cards to the company.

You can even set your asking price and respond to offers from buyers.

There are lots of different categories on the site, such as:

• Sports cards
• Baseball
• Basketball
• Football
• Hockey
• Racing
• Soccer
• Golf
• Tennis
• MMA
• Boxing
• Wrestling

You can choose how you would like to get your earnings once your cards sell.

There are a few options available, such as:

• You can convert the store credit you get into cash.
• You can redeem your store credit to buy sealed boxes and cases.
• Or, you can use the store credit to buy other trading cards or collectibles.

14. The Cardboard Connection

The Cardboard Connection is another good place to sell sports cards online. The site buys baseball cards, football cards, basketball cards, hockey cards, miscellaneous sports collectibles, and sports memorabilia.

The company has facilitated the sale of more than $1 million worth of sports cards and collectibles.

Complete the form on the website, and The Cardboard Connection will refer you to one of its industry-leading buying partners.

When you have submitted the form, The Cardboard Connection and/or one or more of its vetted network of buying partners will contact you in 1 to 2 business days to learn more about your collection, and to get the buying process rolling.

According to the site, most cards from the 1980s and 1990s have little value, and its buyers are mainly looking for vintage cards from before 1974.

The Cardboard Connection is a good option if you want to get your cards in front of lots of different buyers. There are lots of different categories on the site, such as:

• Baseball
• Basketball
• Football
• Hockey
• Soccer
• WWE

You can sell your old baseball cards, soccer cards, etc., or your entire sports card collection.

15. Sports Card Forum

You can list your sports cards for sale on the Sports Card Forum. This forum has different sections for different sports cards, including:

• Football cards
• Baseball cards
• Hockey cards
• Basketball cards
• Racing cards

So, you could post your cards for sale on the forum. People even post cards that they’re looking for on the forum, so you could have a card that someone is already looking to purchase.

16. 2^nd Markets

2^nd Markets is a website where you can sell your vintage baseball and sports card collection. With more than 30 years’ experience with buying from the public, the company is well-established.

According to 2^nd Markets, no collection is too large.

The company states that it purchases important star baseball cards, and pre-1980 football cards, basketball cards, and other sports cards.

It’s important to note that the company only purchases large collections, rather than single items or small collections, unless they are very valuable.

If you don’t have a large collection of cards to sell, then try one of the other options on the list.

Where to Sell Sports Cards Near Me

You also have plenty of options if you’re looking to sell sports cards near you. While selling online is great, selling locally has its benefits too.

When you sell in person, you often get cash on the spot, and you don’t have to worry about shipping your cards anywhere.

Try these places if you want to sell sports cards locally.

17. Local card shops

Although there may not be quite as many local card shops around as there used to be, they’re still a worthwhile option.

If you do have a local card shop nearby, then you should consider asking them if they’ll purchase your sports cards.

You can find local card stores by going to Google, or whatever search engine you use, and then entering the phrase, “sports card stores near me” into the search bar. You could also enter the type of sports card you have, like “football card stores near me” or “baseball card stores near me,” into a search engine.

Hit enter and it will show you if there are any nearby stores that sell sports cards. You can then call to check if these stores purchase sports cards.

It’s important to note that selling to local card stores doesn’t always get you as much money as you’d get selling on sites like eBay. This is because these types of stores usually purchase cards for a lower price than their value, so that they can resell them at a higher price.

18. Yard sales

You could consider selling your cards at a yard sale. Yard sales are a good option because you can often tap into a market of people who may not really shop online.

You can also set your own prices too. I’d recommend a yard sale if you have some less valuable cards and are just looking to get some quick cash for them.

You can get cash on the spot for your sports cards.

19. Craigslist

Craigslist is an awesome site for selling stuff because, well, it’s free to list items for sale on there, and you don’t have to pay any commission on your cards either! Great, right?

You can list your cards for sale on Craigslist and sell them to people nearby.

20. Pawn shops

If you want to know who buys sports cards near you, then try your local pawn shop. Many of them will purchase sports cards.

It’s important to note though that pawn shops likely won’t offer you the best prices for your cards. This is because they typically want to purchase your cards at a lower price than their value so that they can resell them for a profit.

Still though, pawn shops are an option worth considering if you’re looking to sell sports cards for quick cash as they usually pay you on the spot.

Game On, Cash In: Sell Your Sports Cards for Cash Today!

Don’t just let your sports cards sit around and gather dust.

Sell them instead!

There are plenty of places you can sell sports cards both online and near you! You could get yourself extra money to purchase something else you need or just save the cash.