8 Best Places to Sell Your Old Magazines for Cash (See if Yours Are Worth Money?)

If you know what to look for (and where to sell) turning old magazines into actual cash is completely doable.

In this guide I’ll show you the whole process step-by-step: how to figure out whether your magazines are worth anything, the best platforms to sell on, how to prep them so buyers trust you, and even how to ship them without bending, creasing, or destroying the value.

By the way, if you are into magazines, you may be interested in learning how to earn money by writing for them. Check out our guide on how to get paid to submit tips to magazines.

Let’s get you paid without wasting time.

Which Old Magazines Are Worth Money?

Not every magazine is gold. Most aren’t.

Here’s how to quickly spot the ones collectors actually care about.

The “Golden Era” (Pre-1970)

Magazines published before 1970 are usually the sweet spot for collectors.

Why?

They capture historic events, cultural milestones, and early celebrity appearances that newer issues can’t match.

Plus, fewer copies have survived in good condition, so rarity drives value.

Top Value Categories

• Fashion: Vogue, Harper’s Bazaar, early Elle issues
• Gaming: Nintendo Power, early GamePro, Game Informer classics
• Celebrity & Pop Culture: Playboy, Rolling Stone, LIFE milestone covers
• Hobbyist: Car & Driver, Hot Rod, Model Railroader, Scientific American
• Sci-Fi & Comics: Starlog, MAD Magazine, early Marvel and DC fan mags

The “Factice/Partial” Value

Some magazines hold value only when complete. Inserts, posters, or pull-out comics can make a huge difference in price.

For example, early Nintendo Power issues with the original posters or gaming guides included often sell for double what the same issue without them would fetch.

If pages or inserts are missing, you’re looking at a serious drop in collector interest.

What Is Worthless? (The National Geographic Rule)

Here’s the reality check: just because a magazine is old doesn’t mean it’s valuable.

Common titles, recent issues, or heavily damaged magazines (like ripped National Geographics or wet, moldy stacks) typically have little to no resale value.

It’s better to recycle or donate these than waste time trying to sell them.

Where to Sell Old Magazines

Here are the best places to sell your old magazines.

1. eBay: The Volume King

For sheer reach and potential value, eBay is unbeatable.

It’s where collectors hunt for rare covers, milestone issues, and niche magazines.

Before listing, always check sold listings to see what similar issues actually sold for (this is the real market value, not just asking prices.).

Tips: Use clear photos, title formulas like “Magazine Title + Issue Date + Key Feature + Condition”, and specify if inserts or posters are included.

2. Etsy: Vintage & Craft Market

Etsy is perfect if you have visually stunning vintage magazines.

Think art, design, and pop culture covers. Bundles, framed covers, and ephemera often sell better here than whole stacks.

3. Professional Ephemera Dealers

While the “we buy any magazine” sites of the past are mostly gone, specialized dealers who sell on AbeBooks or at paper shows are often looking for specific stock.

If you have a very large, focused collection (e.g., 50 years of Time), look for dealers who specialize in that genre and email them directly with a list.

4. Local Used Bookstores (Half Price Books)

Local used bookstores like Half Price Books are great for clearing out bulk lots.

They typically pay low, but you get cash fast.

Expect about $5–$20 for stacks of common titles, though rare issues may fetch more.

5. Mercari: Mid-Range Bundles

Mercari is an excellent middle ground. It’s easier to list on than eBay and has a younger user base that loves pop-culture nostalgia.

This is a great place to sell bundles of mid-value magazines like 90s gaming or music publications.

6. Facebook Marketplace: Avoid Shipping

Local pickup makes Facebook Marketplace great for large stacks, especially heavy magazines like National Geographic or car magazines.

Negotiate in person, meet safely in public spots, and you’ll get cash immediately.

7. Consignment Shops / Antique Malls

If your collection has verified vintage appeal, consignment shops and antique malls are excellent options.

They handle the selling for you, but the trade-off is usually a 30–50% commission.

8. Paper & Ephemera Shows

For collectors who love niche items, paper shows and ephemera events are the ultimate venues.

These are especially good for rare covers, historical issues, or magazines with unique inserts.

You’ll reach serious buyers who understand true value.

How to Sell Your Magazines for More Money

Before you list any magazine, spend a few minutes grading its condition.

This not only helps you price it correctly but also builds trust with buyers.

• Mint / Near Mint: Crisp, clean cover, no tears, no writing, pages intact, minimal yellowing.
• Good: Light wear on edges or spine, minor yellowing, small creases, but still complete.
• Poor: Significant creases, tears, missing pages or inserts, water or mold damage. Only sell these if they have rarity value or as ephemera.

Preparing for Sale

How you prep magazines can make a real difference in price:

• Remove odors: Freeze smelly magazines for 24–48 hours, or use kitty litter in a sealed container for a few hours.
• Flatten pages: Place under a heavy book overnight to reduce curling.
• Do NOT remove address labels or staples: This can damage the magazine and drop its value.
• Handle carefully: Always touch the edges and avoid bending the cover.

Listing Tips

Once your magazine is graded and prepped, the listing itself can make or break the sale.

• Title template: Magazine Title + Issue Date + Key Feature/Celebrity + Condition (e.g., “LIFE Magazine July 1969 Moon Landing – Very Good”).
• Photos: Cover, spine, back, key pages, inserts, and any defects. Clear, well-lit images boost buyer confidence.
• Description: Include grading, completeness (posters, inserts), smoke/pet-free note, and shipping info.

How to Ship Magazines You Sell Online

Shipping magazines is tricky because paper is heavy and bends easily.

Here is how to do it without losing money.

Do Not Use Media Mail

This is the most common mistake beginners make.

You might think magazines qualify for the cheaper USPS “Media Mail” rate, but they do not.

Magazines have advertisements, which strictly disqualifies them from Media Mail.

If a postal inspector checks your package, it will be returned or the buyer will be charged “Postage Due,” which guarantees negative feedback.

Always check current USPS guidelines here before shipping.

How to Pack Safely

Magazines are thin, flexible, and prone to bending.

Here’s how to pack them correctly:

• Bag & Board Method: Slip the magazine into a poly bag and sandwich it between two pieces of rigid cardboard. Tape the edges securely. This is the same method comic sellers use and works great for single issues or small stacks.
• Cardboard Sandwich: For multiple magazines, stack them neatly, place a piece of cardboard on top and bottom, and wrap with kraft paper or bubble wrap. Use a snug box that prevents movement.

The Best Shipping Service

For a single magazine, the best service is usually USPS Ground Advantage (formerly First Class Package). It includes tracking and is the most cost-effective for items under 1 lb.

Sell, Donate, or Recycle?

Ok, after you sorted and graded your magazines, it’s time to decide what to do with each stack.

Here’s a quick decision table to guide you:

Following this table keeps your selling process efficient and ensures you don’t waste time on magazines that won’t fetch a fair price.

FAQ

Final Thoughts on Selling Old Magazines

Selling old magazines isn’t complicated once you know what to look for.

Now that you know how to sell old magazines, where to list them, how to price them, and how to package them, you’ve got everything you need to turn that dusty box into real cash.

Start by checking a few issues on eBay, snap some clean photos, and get your first listing up today. You might be surprised how much some of these sell for.